This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Find out more.X

Security and legal professionals claim 24-hour breach notification will not be a complete burden

Share this article:
24-hour breach notification 'unfeasible'
24-hour breach notification 'unfeasible'

The proposed 24-hour breach notification law will be a challenge for smaller businesses, but not for enterprises.

Speaking on a recent SC Magazine webcast, Stephen Kerslake, group information security manager at Virgin Media, said that it was not impractical, as the bigger organisations that would have to subscribe to it already have resources in place to support it.

“For example, all the major telcos in the UK have 24/7 security operating or network management facilities whereby a report can be generated instantly,” he said.

“More so, that report will be generated from monitoring network activity across their entire infrastructure and on the detection of a malpractice or an incident, they could very quickly determine what the circumstances were and what needed reporting.

“So I don't think it is unrealistic in our terms, where it may be unrealistic is with a small-to-medium enterprise for example, who don't have the necessary resources.”

Asked if this meant that a ‘one size fits all' template did not work, former information commissioner Richard Thomas, now a consultant at law firm Hunton & Williams, said that he agreed with this. He said that at the moment, it is only the telcos that have a legal obligation to report a breach to the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO), and others are encouraged to report where necessary.

He said: “The worry is, if it becomes mandatory for all organisations to report all breaches, that is really quite burdensome for small and medium businesses, and some larger ones.

“I also worry about the burden on the ICO's shoulders. When you have this blanket approach it becomes very difficult for any regulator to set priorities and work out what is really important, and focus resources on those areas where you need to intervene and take action.”

In agreement with Thomas was Jonathan Armstrong, partner at law firm Duane Morris, who said that 24-hour reporting was not unrealistic and that some companies limit the number of insiders who know about a breach.

He said: “I'd rather they put their finger in the dyke and stopped the breach and stopped worrying about reporting. In the US, the time doesn't run until law enforcement leave the scene and I would like to see that. Also, if all data is encrypted, should it really be reported? Most of the US statures have that as exemption.

“You also need to take into account notification fatigue; the US has got itself into a mess as people report relatively trivial breaches, so whenever a serious breach happens, people just bin the envelope. That increases the burden on everyone.”

Thomas said that the real priority is not to take steps to notify people, but to stop the breach. Kerslake also said that an online facility for organisations to report into the ICO would be better, and said that this could be used as an awareness facility on what is important in terms of reporting and what is not.

Share this article:

SC webcasts on demand

This is how to secure data in the cloud


Exclusive video webcast & Q&A sponsored by Vormetric


As enterprises look to take advantage of the cloud, they need to understand the importance of safeguarding their confidential and sensitive data in cloud environments. With the appropriate security safeguards, such as fine-grained access policies, a move to the cloud is as, or more, secure than an on-premise data storage.


View the webcast here to find out more

More in News

VC cyber security funding tops £850 million

VC cyber security funding tops £850 million

A new study from US-based research firm CBI Insights reveals that corporate cyber security investments have risen five-fold since 2009, with 30 percent growth in the last year alone.

Russian/Chinese cyber-security pact raises concerns

Russian/Chinese cyber-security pact raises concerns

News that Russia and China are set to sign a cyber-security treaty next month have left Western cyber experts unsure whether it is a threat or a promising development.

UK police arrest trio over £1.6 million cyber theft from cash machines

UK police arrest trio over £1.6 million cyber ...

London Police have arrested three suspected members of an Eastern European cyber-crime gang who installed malware on more than 50 bank ATM machines across the UK to steal £1.6 million.